Originally Posted By: danb
We had progress in any field but not on this.
Still I do not get it.


Why, Dan, have you not progressed this? Sheesh! wink


Originally Posted By: Borzki
What is your opinion in the torsional and axial SIF's which is now available in this tools.
I am doing one analysis and it has an impact (it qualifies without it and fails if I include it).


My opinion is if you have better information to indicate failure, then it fails.

If someone strong arms you into doing it a certain way, then you denote such.

"By stamping this document, I am authenticating the adherence of this piping configuration to the codes and standards as laid out by the end user, and am not qualifying its actual suitability, whose responsibility belongs to the end user. I note the suitability is called into question based on the calculations as determined by..."