There are several problems with the example in Appendix P:

1) When pulling values from the curves, the example doesn't interpolate, it just uses the closest value. CAESAR II and TANK interpolate between the curves in the figures P2-A thru P2-F.

2) There is a set of curves for L/2a=1.0 (P2-A thru P2-C) and another set for L/2a=1.5 (P2-D thru P2-F). The example does not interpolate between these two sets of curves - say when L/2a=1.25. CAESAR II and TANK interpolate between these two sets of figures.

3) Intermediate results are rounded in the example. CAESAR II and TANK do not round values.
_________________________
Regards,
Richard Ay - Consultant