Deae Khalid,

Please read and understand carefully whole discussion,then you will be clear that I have not said WNC is a hypothetical case.

I described the problem given by Mr.Habib as hypothetical as the problem from you also falls in the same category.

Answer to my following question...please

Are you submitting nozzle evalution sheet for WNC load case with your stress analysis report as a deliverable for any of the equipment nozzle irespective of the type of restaint used to support your piping?I repeat, nozzle evaluation sheet for WNC load case

Answer to this question as straight as I asked honestly.The If and but for any justification we will discuss after this answer.

Regards,
Aslam