Sir,
The project bid document says that "Seismic analysis shall be based on a linear dynamic analysis based on modal & spectral analysis. The applicable response spectrum are those applicable to their support anchor point locations. In addition to inertial effect, differential anchor motion shall be taken into account ."
Now our defense is that we can apply same spectrum for piping running on sleepers and on pipe rack of 8.0 m TOS ( same piping continues from sleepers to rack) since we are already superimposing the pipe rack structural deflections in response spectrum module and not static module. Pipe rack deflections are due to seismic event.
Now that we are applying pipe rack deflections at supports derived from pipe rack , why we need to additionally use different spectrum at 8.0 m ?
There is one more issue -
Since there are displacements superimposed , whether we can compare the induced stresses with displacement stress range , i.e. ( EXP) and not with OCC limits , i.e. 1.33 SH ? In dynamic module whether we need to make the stress check case as EXP ?
This is as per 319.2.1 (d) of 31/3 which says that-
"Thermal displacements , reaction displacements ,and externally imposed displacements all have equivalent effects on the piping system , and shall be considered together in determining the total displacement strains ( proportional deformations )in various parts of the piping system"
Regards,
bag_piper