Thanks for your Valuable information Mr. Mandeep singh & Richard,
In our project, after qualifying the nozzle in both WRC 107 & 297 also client require to do PD5500 check.
A. They mention the following statements.
WRC 107 checks only for Vessel side.
WRC 297 check for both NOZZLE & VESSEL side
PD5500 is used to check the compressive buckling check.
In WRC, this type of (compressive buckling check) stress check is not there?
B. As you said. “PD5500 ANNEX G is similar to WRC 107”. So PD5500 also calculating stress on vessel side only?
C. As you said, “WRC 297 while only is calculating NOZZLE TO NOZZLE intersections.” It Means: used only for cylindered type nozzles not for spherical nozzle.
D. As you said”, PD5500 applies a SCF for pressure stresses”
I think PD/2eas is the formulae for Fp (Pressure-hoop stress) and that value is adding to membrane stress (sub total). I didn’t find that SCF multification factor in my hand calculations. whether in my case SCF=1? & I didn’t find any input for pressure SCF in CAESAR-II PD5500 module? Can you please provide reference. It helps in my future works.
Please correct me if I am wrong.
Thanks In advance.
_________________________
Thanks,
Durga