about the MW kellog trunion desing

hi everybody,
Several months ago there were a discussion about the analysis of SIF´s in trunnions. i hope it´s not too late to ask for a copy of MW Kellog trunnion desing. Can anyone, please, send me this document to johanehb@gmail.com? Thanks and regards

With reference to the above post and to the previous thread covering discussion of trunnion design, I too would be profoundly thankful if anyone could send me a copy of the original MW Kellogg papers on trunnion design. My e-mail address is ketil.huseby@promech.no.

Regards,

The echo of M.W. Kellogg’s trunnion design approach seems never to rest, despite more accurate, readily available WRC or FEA methods.

That said, the reputed reliability of its design, in all honesty, lies not so much in the stress analysis of it as in a Kellogg’s engineering practice.

Contrasting to many dummy-leg designers relishing to use “pin leg” pipe supports, Kellogg’s engineering practice as I recall requires that the diameter of a trunnion be always larger than half-size of the supported pipe. Coincidentally or not, none of Kellogg-designed trunnions have had reported failure.

Good stress analysis or good engineering practice?

Maybe both!!! They often go hand in hand!

Johane,

Please, call me 2046653

Regards, Roberto

hello all.
I'll dig out the copy i sent previously.
Plus i'll sent the revised version as promised.
Give me a day or two.

I would be very grateful if I could get a copy of the paper too. My email is adam.gifford@worleyparsons.com

Superpiper, Request you to send me a copy of original MW Kellogg papers on trunnion design if possible.

email: s_g_ramkumar@yahoo.com


Regards,

Superpiper, may I request too copies of the documents you are mentioning including the revisions. I have too from some senior guys which seems to be a revised one from those early papers I got from Kellog. If yours are different, I'll email too scanned copies of the latest ones I got. Thanks a lot for your generousity. My email adress: Ed-Lamigo@cox.net.

Please send me a copy of this also. craig.biddle@wgint.com

Superpiper please send to me a copy of above document.gpskumar22@yahoo.co.in

regards

hey, this is good reference... i surely appreciate if you could also send me a copy of it. prete@atomtech.com.tw

ty and regards,

Ok.
E-mailed as promised.

I look forward to some discussion on the contents.

Superpiper,I was following this subject in the forum and now becaouse it come up please send also to me a copy of the document in subject at:dorin.petrea@naoc.agip.it
I'll highly appreciate your effort,
Regards

Hello Superpiper

I appreciate if you could send me a copy of it.

My e-mail is: roberto.bonavino@inelectra.com

Regards, Roberto

I would be very grateful if you could send me copy of the paper too. My email is nareshpandit@gmail.com.

thanx in advace.

naresh

Hellow Naresh Sharma,
I will send you copy of the MW kellog trunion design manual at earliest.

regards

I need a copy too.

Please send it to adesoji.adegboyega@qed-international.com

Thanks

Hi Superpiper,

I'll apreciate having a copy of this interesting document too. I think it would be better if you posted it on the forum. So anybody who wants could register and download a copy themselves.

My email ID is hashkart@gmail.com

thanks,
Harish.

Hi Superpiper,

I'll apreciate having a copy of this interesting document too. I think it would be better if you posted it on the forum. So anybody who wants could register and download a copy themselves.

My email ID is hashkart@gmail.com

thanks,
Harish.

SUPERPIPER

Please send me also at

tushar.rajyaguru@gmail.com

Thanks

Brain the size of a planet.................

I can't do this.

righty- o then..............

SuperPiper....

This method is quite old and is not nearly as current as the NC Cases... the NC cases are very conservative but widely used in the power industry....

The Author whom I have sipped an adult beverage with states the level of conservatisom was as requested by the sponsor.... EPRI

Both NC cases are published and described in WRC 448...

Superpiper, please send me a copy of original MW Kellogg papers on trunnion design also. if possible.

E-MAIL : totojeff@hanmail.net

Best Regards.

Click the link in the post above!

i will be grateful in any one send me a copy of MW Kellogg papers on trunnion design
my email id is rajkmr_83@hotmail.com

i will be grateful in any one send me a copy of MW Kellogg papers on trunnion design
my email id is rajkmr_83@hotmail.com

Does nobody actually read the previous posts?
The Kellogg Papers are available on page 3 of this topic in a post by the honourable Superpiper. Look for the words ATTACHMENT as a hint