Dear Ray/Mandeep,
I have been asked by my chief to compare rigging analysis results with hand calcs (we have recently acquired PVelite for this purpose).
After performing hand calcs (case 1. All loads as uniformly distributed loads (UDL), case 2: UDLs+concentrated loads):
1. My reaction forces at lifting and tailing come within acceptable margin than those reported by PVElite.
2. The Maximum bending stress location was also predicted correctly.
3. However and here's my question, my bending stresses are way higher than those predicted by PVelite (including the max bending stress).
Please note I'm also considering an impact factor of 1.5 in my hand calcs as well as the software.
For bending stress, I'm using
Sigmab=M.y/I (M=Bending moment)
I=pi/4(Ro^2-Ri^2)
y=ID/2
Please provide information on how PVElite calculates the bending stresses.
I believe there may be certain assumptions in your case (or mine) which may be causing the difference.
Thank you in advance for your assistance.
Regards,
Suhas.