Which scenario is advisable for restraint summary report,

Dear experts,

Kindly advise me what are the load case to be considered for restraint summary report for support design.

Scenario-1

Hydro test Case (L1) WW+HP
Operating Case (L2) W+T1+P1
Operating Case (L3) W+T2+P1
Sustained Case (L4) W+P1

Scenario-2

RESTRAIT SUMMARY REPORT

Hydro test Case (L1) WW+HP
Operating Case (L2) W+T1+P1
Operating Case (L3) W+T2+P1
Sustained Case (L4) W+P1
Expansion Case (L5) L2-L4
Expansion Case (L6) L3-L4

Two scenarios are show in table, in this which Scenario is advisable for restraint summary report, if any portrayal for report output method.

Regards

rajiv

Dear experts,

Advice me which one is correct for output restraint summary report for support design.

Regards

Rajiv

Your expansion cases are "range" cases. These cases will yield the range of loads on the restraints, not the actual restraint loads.

From what you've listed above, you want Scenario 1.